Abstract
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic is exacting a
disproportionate toll on ethnic minority communities and magnifying
existing disparities in health care access and treatment. To understand
this crisis, physicians and public health researchers have searched
history for insights, especially from a great outbreak approximately a
century ago: the 1918 influenza pandemic. However, of the accounts
examining the 1918 influenza pandemic and COVID-19, only a notable few
discuss race. Yet, a rich, broader scholarship on race and epidemic
disease as a “sampling device for social analysis” exists. This
commentary examines the historical arc of the 1918 influenza pandemic,
focusing on black Americans and showing the complex and sometimes
surprising ways it operated, triggering particular responses both within
a minority community and in wider racial, sociopolitical, and public
health structures. This analysis reveals that critical structural
inequities and health care gaps have historically contributed to and
continue to compound disparate health outcomes among communities of
color. Shifting from this context to the present, this article frames a
discussion of racial health disparities through a resilience approach
rather than a deficit approach and offers a blueprint for approaching
the COVID-19 crisis and its afterlives through the lens of health
equity.
The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic has killed more than 100 000 persons in the United States (
1).
Nationwide data indicate that ethnic minority communities, particularly
black, Latinx, and Native or indigenous communities, suffer
disproportionately (
2–7).
This has significant historical antecedents; as Evelynn Hammonds
recently argued, epidemic diseases “lay bare and make visible
inequalities in a society” (
8). Yet, at the onset of the crisis, few reported its effect on minorities (
9).
Even now, we may not know the full scope and details. Many states have
published limited statistics, and race-stratified data, once fully
released, will need to be carefully interpreted to address the causes of
inequity rather than to perpetuate stigma and discrimination (
10).
Unfortunately, this comes as no surprise to health equity researchers
and historians of medicine and public health. The United States has a
long history of racial and socioeconomic disparities, with the current
pandemic further revealing the rifts created by historical injustice,
structural racism, and interpersonal bias (
11–13).
Although some have touted COVID-19 as a “great equalizer” that strikes
across age, sex, race/ethnicity, and geography, we contend that it has
magnified the many “unequalizers” in our society (
14,
15).
To understand the current crisis, physicians and public health researchers have mined history for insights (
16).
Most have focused on a century-old outbreak, the 1918 influenza
pandemic (misleadingly called the “Spanish flu”), because COVID-19 most
closely approximates it in scope and effect (
17–19). Of the accounts comparing the 1918 influenza pandemic and COVID-19, only a notable few discuss race (
8,
20,
21). Yet, a rich, broader scholarship on race and epidemic disease as a “sampling device for social analysis” exists (
22–27).
Given the excessive mortality due to COVID-19 in minority communities,
reexamination of such historical antecedents is fruitful. Although this
scholarship hesitates to offer predictions, this kind of analysis can
provide orienting frameworks, reveal nuance, and modulate our approach
to the current crisis—which has been called “unprecedented,” reflecting a
lack of historical context.
We examine the historical arc of the 1918 influenza pandemic,
focusing on black Americans and showing the complex, sometimes
surprising ways it triggered particular responses both within a minority
community and in wider racial, sociopolitical, and public health
structures. Shifting to the present, we frame a discussion of racial
health disparities through a resilience approach versus a deficit
approach and offer a blueprint (
Table) for approaching the COVID-19 crisis and its afterlives through the lens of health equity.